Directors: Faith Akin, Yvan Attal...Writers: Jeff Nathason, Anthony Minghella...
Starring: Natalie Portman, Shia Labeouf, Bradley Cooper
Release Date: October 16, 2009
Length: 1 hour 43 minutes
In 2006, producers Emmanuel Benbihy and Tristan Carne brought us a remarkably beautiful movie about love in the city where anything’s possible. Paris Je T’aime was a collection of multiple five-minute films that showed love between all people. Now the same producers give us a movie about love in the city that never sleeps. This film includes 15 stories of love in the five boroughs of New York City. Extraordinary directors, including Yvan Ataal and Joshua Marston, directed New York, I Love You. Each director delivered a unique story that was interesting to watch. The downside to having a five-minute film is that the story and relationships between characters can be confusing or left unexplained. This was used to the filmmakers’ advantages for some films giving an effect of things that aren’t always, as they seem. For example, you could believe that two characters would be strangers, when, in fact, they are spouses. There were quite a lot of films that had that theme. Although the film kept a nice diversity of different stories, some of them seemed alike and by the end of the film I confused a lot of stories with each other for being so similar. I found that I enjoyed Paris Je T’aime much more than I enjoyed New York, I Love You. I partly believe that is because Paris, Je T’aime had a much wider variety of different stories, different styles of filming, and capturing different parts of the city than New York I love You. I might have also liked Paris, Je Taime more because I have been to New York and I have never been to Paris. The underlying theme for New York, I Love You was obviously love in all forms, love between siblings, or mother and child, or lovers, or even unrequited love. Some short films seemed to stray away from that theme, even if they were still enjoyable. Some stories just had a character living in New York. Most of the short films I really enjoyed and was intrigued by all of them, but when you put all the short films together - even when stringed together by the character played by Emile Ohana (a tourist of New York) – the film didn’t seem as amazing as an entire project. What I did like about New York, I love You was that the filmmakers seemed to capture different parts of New York City without the film shouting “Look, we are in Times Square” or “Look, we are in Soho.” To me, it was not a necessity to have every single famous area or building in New York shown in this film. There were obviously some stories I liked more than others, for example the film written, directed and starring Natalie Portman was fun to watch and a film with Orlando Bloom and Christina Ricci was also a nice story. There were obviously some duds in the movie, but how can a person honestly enjoy 15 different stories in a row. There are more winners than losers in New York, I Love You.






